un dato

Import Businesses for Claps Flourish Even in the United Arab Emirates

Turkey and the coastal emirates of the Arabian Peninsula are now the homes of companies that supply the main social -and clientelist- program of the Government of Venezuela. Although the move from Mexico and Hong Kong, seems geographically epic, the companies has not changed hands. They are still owned by Colombian entrepreneurs Alex Nain Saab Morán and Álvaro Pulido Vargas, who control since 2016 a good part of the Import of food financed with public funds. Around the world for a business.  



Disponible también en:


Este reportaje se encuentra disponible también en:

Just five months ago, on April 6, 2018, a letter from Group Grand Limited arrived at the office of the then president of the Venezuelan Foreign Trade Corporation (Corpovex), Major General (Aviation) Giuseppe Yoffreda Yorio. In the letter, the company asked the state body responsible for public imports the "assignment of financial rights of contract CPVX-CJ-CONT-0086-2017" of Mulberry Proje Yatirim A.S, incorporated in Istanbul, Turkey.

As Armando.Info has revealed in several reports, Group Grand Limited, registered in Hong Kong, is one of the legal facades behind which Colombian entrepreneurs Alex Nain Saab Morán and Álvaro Pulido Vargas hid, and whereby the couple has become almost omnipresent in the business of supplying the main social program of the Government of Nicolás Maduro, the so-called Local Committees for Supply and Production (Clap). As discussed below, Mulberry Proje Yatirim A.S. is another piece of the same plot.

chevron_leftDesliza la imagen para ver máschevron_right

zoom_inHaz click sobre cada imagen para ampliar

Initially developed by the Government to work as production groups that, as party cells, would ensure the supply of food, in practice, the Claps have been restricted to the intermittent and clientelism-based distribution of boxes and bags with products of the basic basket imported from several countries. Thus, they have become a source of shady deals for a handful of entrepreneurs. For the popular sectors, however, they are one of the few alternatives to alleviate the chronic shortage of food that Venezuela is going through.

The letter from Group Grand Limited to Corpovex was signed by Andreína Fuentes Mazzei, as legal representative. However, Fuentes Mazzei has also acted for years as an executive of the Fondo Global de Construcción (Global Construction Fund) in Caracas, which is part of a conglomerate of the same name with headquarters in Colombia, Spain, Ecuador and the Mediterranean island of Malta. It was with Fondo Global de Construcción that the duet of Alex Saab and Álvaro Pulido began their still upward trajectory as contractors of Chavism by reaching in November 2011 the agreement to build a social housing project in Valles del Tuy, southwest of Caracas.

The connection of Fuentes Mazzei with Group Grand Limited is not the only indication that the transfer of the debt from that company to the Turkish Mulberry Proje Yatirim was a virtually incestuous inbred operation between related companies; in other words, from Saab-Pulido to Saab-Pulido.

Mulberry Proje Yatirim is represented by Betsy Desirée Mata Pereda, who is the manager of Salva Foods 2015, the Venezuelan company that runs the CLAP Stores that President Maduro has been promoting since early 2017. Salva Foods belongs to Carlos Rolando Lizcano Manrique, also a Colombian entrepreneur, born in Cúcuta, province of Norte de Santander, and with business ties with Alex Saab and Álvaro Pulido established through Group Grand Limited.

So everything was among the closed ones.

I with Myself

When the "assignment of financial rights" in favor of the Turkish Company Mulberry Proje Yatirim was considered, Group Grand Limited had two contracts with the Government and was, perhaps, the main intermediary for the imports of the Clap. For example, the contract referred to in the letter to Corpovex entailed the sale of 11.5 million Clap boxes for Corporación Única de Servicios Productivos y Alimentarios (Cuspal), attached to the Ministry of Food.

Long before, in the late 2016, Group Grand Limited was favored with what would be its first contract as food importer for the purchase of ten million combos for 340 million dollars agreed upon with the Government of the State of Táchira (the Andes in southwest Venezuela), which was back then led by Army Captain José Gregorio Vielma Mora of the ruling United Socialist Party of Venezuela (PSUV). A millionaire business was born that always goes to the same beneficiaries and does not stop growing. After all, Group Grand Limited was also chosen by the Ministry of Health to import medicines, this time from India.

In the two agreements with the Venezuelan Government for the supply of Clap boxes, the agent of Group Grand Limited before the authorities was Andreína Fuentes Mazzei, the same person that appeared in the letter to Corpovex. On the other hand, the son of Alex Saab, Shadi Nain Saab Certain, appeared as director of the company until February 24, 2017. In addition, the contact address on the incorporation papers of the company is the same of Fondo Global de Construcción in Caracas. Shadi Saab was succeeded by Javier Ernesto Betancourt Valle, a Colombian lawyer, former consul of his country in New York, and whose name will appear again in this business network with a company from the United Arab Emirates. In the Mexican subsidiary of Group Grand Limited, opened and liquidated in 2017, the son of Álvaro Pulido Vargas appeared as the company's proxy for a brief period.


Connection in Istanbul

Although the company was registered on May 7, 2015, Betsy Mata became a member of the board of directors of the Turkish Mulberry Proje Yatirim A.S. only a few months ago. The contact telephone number on the incorporation papers in Istanbul is from Caracas. The documents also reveal the connection of this firm with a British company called Mulberry Capital Partners Limited.

The moving of the apparent epicenter of the Clap business to Turkey does not seem casual. In fact, it may seem natural, and not because the Saab family name goes back to its ancestors in the Middle East. For months, financial intelligence units of at least four American countries have been investigating the money flows behind the CLAP business, after Public Prosecutor General Luisa Ortega Díaz, recently dismissed by Maduro and in exile, reported last August that Group Grand Limited was managed by Alex Saab and Álvaro Pulido on behalf of the Venezuelan president. “We have conducted an investigation on the CLAP food bags delivered in Venezuela by a company registered in Mexico under the name of two people. The company is Group Grand Limited and presumably belongs to the president of the Republic, Nicolás Maduro," declared Ortega Díaz. The message resounded and authorities of several countries started an investigation.

But there is also the political pragmatism of Nicolás Maduro, who in a matter of months has strengthened the relationship with his Turkish counterpart, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, in search of an ally to avoid the financial penalties imposed on both countries by Donald Trump’s administration since mid-last year.

chevron_leftDesliza la imagen para ver máschevron_right

zoom_inHaz click sobre cada imagen para ampliar

"We have brought a thorough document of all investment opportunities. It is the first scenario where Venezuela comes out with a detailed investment proposal," Maduro announced in July from Istanbul before Turkish entrepreneurs. In October 2017, both heads of state set up the "second joint intergovernmental commission" in Ankara, and since then, Venezuelan officials have repeatedly traveled to Turkey. In last year’s November, it was the turn of the Finance Minister, Simón Zerpa, while in January of the current year the then president of the National Constituent Assembly and now Vice President of the Republic, Delcy Rodríguez, as well as the former Minister of Foreign Trade, José Gregorio Vielma Mora, were in the Eurasian nation.

Results did not take long. On August 31, two presidential decrees formalized the link between
state-owned companies Minerven and Carbozulia and Turkish companies for the creation of "joint ventures." Previously, in July, the Venezuelan government confirmed to Reuters that it refines in Turkey the gold extracted from the so-called Mining Arch, in the south of the country. That same month, the Minister of Food, Luis Medina Ramírez, reported on Twitter that he met in Caracas with executives of Yayla, which he defined as the "Turkish agro-food giant" and with which they agreed upon the "cooperation in the supply of food and support to agricultural production." Clap boxes are a mirror of the approach and, for months, some of the eleven products are Turkish-branded and end up in the Venezuelan homes after the Government sells the food combos at subsidized prices.

chevron_leftDesliza la imagen para ver máschevron_right

zoom_inHaz click sobre cada imagen para ampliar

Betsy Mata did not answer the interview request for this report. However, databases specialized in international trade, like Panjiva, provide clues about the role of Mulberry Proje Yatirim in the Clap business. According to this registry, the Turkish company acts as an intermediary of the Venezuelan Government in food importation, as Group Grand Limited has done since 2016. The data confirms that Mulberry Proje Yatirim buys merchandise from Rice & Beans or El Sardinero, both well-known Mexican suppliers and to which Group Grand Limited also resorted regularly to acquire shipments that come, as before, from the port of Veracruz.

Mexican authorities detected that from 2016 to 2017, El Sardinero alone issued "fiscal invoices" to Group Grand Limited for nearly 240 million dollars. "From April 2016 to August 2017, Group Grand Limited sent international transfers from Hong Kong to five different companies in Mexico," as referred to in a document. In that report, Asasi Food FZC stands out ?a United Arab Emirates company, another intermediary of the Claps that began to make a name for itself almost at the same time that Group Grand Limited was disappearing from the business and its Mexican subsidiary - the one that gave rise to the complaint filed by Prosecutor Ortega Díaz in 2017 - initiated the bankruptcy proceeding.

chevron_leftDesliza la imagen para ver máschevron_right

zoom_inHaz click sobre cada imagen para ampliar

‘Arabia Felix’ for Some

Asasi Food FZC also became part of the Alex Saab and Álvaro Pulido business plot. Sources claim that Group Grand Limited did not only assign financial rights to Mulberry Proje Yatirim, but also to Asasi Food FZC. Although this version could not be reliably confirmed for this release, a primary connection point was found between the pair of Colombian entrepreneurs and the UAE company.

The link is in the commercial file of Salva Foods 2015, the Venezuelan company responsible for the CLAP Stores. In those papers, there is an unsuccessful attempt to sell Salva Foods 2015 to Asasi Food FZC. "Cancellation of sale to Asasi Food FZC", reads a handwritten sheet of the book of shareholders, almost lost among the other pages. Asasi Food FZC was represented in that act by Jorge Wuerms, Panamanian, and Javier Betancourt, the Colombian lawyer who succeeded Alex Saab's son as director of Group Grand Limited. "Asasi Food FZC is a company that aims to meet the basic needs of mankind through agro-industrial development," the company claims on its website.

Although the sale failed, the participation of Asasi Food FZC in the Clap business was registered in Panjiva, in addition to the money movements detected by the Mexican authorities. Asasi Food FZC bought food from Mexican industrialists and sold it to the Venezuelan government. Some of those suppliers were El Sardinero, Molinos de Azteca de Chalco and Grupo Brandon. The latter has become this year the main supplier of milk powder that arrives in Venezuela in the Clap boxes, despite of being completely unknown to the Mexican dairy industry and the poor nutritional quality that some of its products showed after being analyzed by the Institute of Food Science and Technology of Universidad Central de Venezuela at the request of Armando.Info.

chevron_leftDesliza la imagen para ver máschevron_right

zoom_inHaz click sobre cada imagen para ampliar

Sources familiar with the business state that the money movements of Asasi Food FZC were made through Noor Capital PSC bank, also from the United Arab Emirates.

Salva Foods 2015’s file shows another failed transfer attempt. The owner, Carlos Lizcano, also tried to sell the company responsible for the CLAP Stores to L & L Inversiones SAS, a Colombian company that he also owns and according to importgenius.com, was a supplier of Abastos Bicentenario in 2015, the same sales network that was finally replaced by the CLAP Stores. In addition, late last year, L & L Inversiones SAS shipped merchandise to Salva Foods 2015.

Last May, Carlos Lizcano, who has evaded the interview requests, transferred the majority shareholding of Salva Foods 2015 to another company that he represented, incorporated in Abu Dhabi, one of the seven Arab emirates on the coasts of the Persian Gulf, thousands of kilometers from Venezuela. Just before the sale of shares, the capital of Salva Foods 2015 increased from 2,000 million bolivars (currently, two million bolívares soberanos or just over $ 30,000 at the official rate) to 50,000 million bolivars (50 million bolívares soberanos, almost $ 850,000 at the official rate) that were finally divided between Mezedes Holding Ltd, with 65.97%, and Carlos Lizcano, with 34.02%.

chevron_leftDesliza la imagen para ver máschevron_right

zoom_inHaz click sobre cada imagen para ampliar

The Abu Dhabi company register confirms that Mezedes Holding Ltd was created on April 10, 2018, just four days after that letter whereby Group Grand Limited assigned its financial rights to the Turkish company. It is proof, at least, that in the end, the plan to feed the poorest in Venezuela, formalized by Maduro in March 2016, benefits a company nominally incorporated in one of the richest places on the planet.

chevron_leftDesliza la imagen para ver máschevron_right

zoom_inHaz click sobre cada imagen para ampliar

¡Hola! Gracias por leer nuestro artículo.

A diferencia de muchos medios de comunicación digital, Armandoinfo no ha adoptado el modelo de subscripción para acceder a nuestro contenido. Nuestra misión es hacer periodismo de investigación sobre la situación en Venezuela y sacar a la luz lo que los poderosos no quieren que sepas. Por eso nos hemos ganado importantes premios como el Pulitzer por nuestros trabajos con los Papeles de Panamá y el premio Maria Moors Cabot otorgado por la Universidad de Columbia.

Para poder continuar con esa misión, te pedimos que consideres hacer un aporte. El dinero servirá para financiar el trabajo investigativo de nuestros periodistas y mantener el sitio para que la verdad salga al aire.

Gracias por leernos. Recuerda que al final del texto puedes contribuir con nuestras investigaciones, disfrutar otros formatos y leer otras historias.